HGTY

Financial Services

Hagerty, Inc. · Insurance - Property & Casualty · $4B

UQS Score — Balanced Preset
46.3
Below Average

Hagerty, Inc. scores 46.3/100 using the Balanced preset.

UQS vs Financial Services Sector
HGTY
46.3
Sector avg
39.7
Quality
Weak
Moat
Neutral
Growth
Good
Risk
Weak
Valuation
Good

What is Hagerty, Inc.?

Hagerty, Inc. is a specialty insurance and automotive lifestyle company focused on collector vehicles and enthusiast experiences. Headquartered in Traverse City, Michigan, it serves a passionate niche audience of car and boat collectors worldwide.

Hagerty generates revenue primarily through insurance agency services covering collector automobiles and boats, alongside reinsurance products. Beyond insurance, the company operates a membership platform offering a magazine, events, roadside assistance, and vehicle valuation tools. It also runs DriveShare, a peer-to-peer rental platform for collector vehicles, and Hagerty Garage + Social, which provides car storage and clubhouse facilities for enthusiasts.

Hagerty went public in 2021 and is headquartered in Traverse City, Michigan.

  • Collector automobile and boat insurance products
  • HDC membership with magazine, events, and roadside services
  • HVT vehicle valuation tool for historic pricing data
  • DriveShare peer-to-peer collector vehicle rental platform
  • Hagerty Garage + Social car storage and clubhouse facilities

Is HGTY a Good Stock to Buy?

UQS Score rates HGTY as Below Average overall, reflecting a mixed picture across its five quality pillars.

Hagerty's Growth pillar stands out as a relative bright spot, suggesting the company is expanding its footprint within the collector vehicle niche. Valuation also registers as Good, meaning the stock does not appear richly priced relative to its fundamentals — a potential point of interest for patient investors.

The Risk pillar is rated Weak, which is the most significant concern in the profile. Quality and Moat both land at Neutral, indicating the business has not yet established a clearly defensible competitive position or consistent financial strength.

See the exact pillar breakdown and full financial metrics by signing up for a UQS Pro account. Sign up free →

Past performance does not guarantee future results. UQS Score is based on fundamental data and is not a buy/sell recommendation.

Does HGTY pay dividends?

No — Hagerty, Inc. does not currently pay a dividend.

Hagerty does not currently pay a dividend. As a growth-oriented company still building out its membership ecosystem and expanding its insurance platform, capital is directed toward business development rather than shareholder distributions. Investors seeking income from this position should look elsewhere for yield.

When does HGTY report earnings?

Hagerty reports earnings on a quarterly cadence, consistent with US-listed equities.

The company's results reflect ongoing investment in its membership platform and insurance operations, with growth initiatives running alongside elevated costs. Progress in subscriber and policyholder counts tends to be the key metric investors watch each quarter.

For the most recent quarter's results and guidance, visit Hagerty's investor relations page directly.

HGTY Price History

+9.6% over 5Y

Monthly close, adjusted for stock splits and dividend reinvestment.

Return Calculator

What if I invested in Hagerty, Inc.?

$
Today it would be worth
$12,457
That's a +24.6% total return, or +24.6% annualized.

Based on Hagerty, Inc.'s historical closing prices, adjusted for stock splits and dividend reinvestment. Past performance does not guarantee future results. This is for informational purposes only and is not financial advice.

HGTY Long-term Outlook

Hagerty's fundamental outlook is shaped by its Good Growth profile, which points to continued expansion in its core insurance and membership segments. However, the Weak Risk rating signals meaningful uncertainty — whether from underwriting exposure, competitive pressure, or the capital demands of scaling a multi-platform lifestyle brand. The Good Valuation label suggests the market has not priced in an optimistic scenario, leaving room for upside if execution improves.

Growth drivers

  • Expanding HDC membership base and recurring subscription revenue
  • Growing collector vehicle market and rising demand for specialty insurance
  • Platform diversification through DriveShare, events, and garage services

Key risks

  • Elevated risk profile that could pressure margins or require additional capital
  • Dependence on a niche enthusiast market that may be sensitive to economic cycles
  • Execution risk across multiple simultaneous platform expansions

HGTY vs Peers

Hagerty operates in specialty insurance alongside several more established carriers, each with a distinct market focus.

PLMRHGTY scores lower
Palomar Holdings, Inc.

Palomar focuses on specialty property insurance for catastrophe-exposed risks, giving it a different underwriting profile than Hagerty's collector vehicle niche.

IFC-PA.TOHGTY scores lower
Intact Financial Corporation

Intact is a large Canadian-based insurer with broad personal and commercial lines, operating at a significantly larger scale than Hagerty.

SIGIHGTY scores lower
Selective Insurance Group, Inc.

Selective serves standard commercial and personal lines in the US, with a regional agency model that contrasts with Hagerty's enthusiast-community approach.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does Hagerty do?

Hagerty provides specialty insurance for collector automobiles and boats, alongside reinsurance products. It also operates a membership platform, vehicle valuation tools, a peer-to-peer rental marketplace called DriveShare, and physical car storage facilities under the Hagerty Garage + Social brand.

Does HGTY pay dividends?

No, Hagerty does not currently pay a dividend. The company is in a growth phase, reinvesting capital into its insurance operations and lifestyle platform rather than returning cash to shareholders through distributions.

When does HGTY report earnings?

Hagerty reports on a quarterly cadence like most US-listed companies. The company does not pre-announce specific dates far in advance, so check Hagerty's investor relations page for the current earnings calendar.

Is HGTY a good stock to buy?

UQS Score rates HGTY as Below Average overall. The Growth and Valuation pillars are relatively constructive, but the Weak Risk rating is a meaningful concern. Whether it fits a portfolio depends on an investor's risk tolerance and time horizon — the full pillar breakdown is available to Pro members.

Is HGTY overvalued?

The UQS Valuation pillar for HGTY is rated Good, suggesting the stock is not trading at a stretched premium relative to its fundamentals. That said, valuation alone does not determine investment merit — the Risk and Quality pillars also matter significantly.

How does HGTY compare to its competitors?

Hagerty occupies a distinct niche compared to broader specialty insurers like Palomar Holdings or Selective Insurance Group. Its collector vehicle focus and lifestyle membership model set it apart, though its scale and financial profile are smaller than most peers in the [specialty insurance sector](/sector/financial-services).

What is HGTY's market cap bracket?

Hagerty is classified as a mid-cap company. This places it in a range where growth potential remains meaningful but institutional coverage and liquidity may be more limited than large-cap peers.

Who founded Hagerty?

Hagerty was founded by Frank and Louise Hagerty and has grown from a family-run specialty insurer into a publicly traded automotive lifestyle company. The company went public in 2021. Founding details are widely available through Hagerty's official history.

Is HGTY a long-term quality investment?

From a long-term quality perspective, HGTY's UQS profile shows a Neutral Quality and Moat rating, meaning the business has not yet demonstrated the durable competitive advantages or consistent financial strength typically associated with high-conviction long-term holdings. The Weak Risk pillar adds further caution for long-duration investors.

What is the main competitive advantage of Hagerty?

Hagerty's primary differentiator is its deep integration with the collector car community — combining insurance, media, events, valuation tools, and storage under one brand. This ecosystem approach creates switching costs and community loyalty that a standard insurer would find difficult to replicate quickly.

What sector does HGTY belong to?

Hagerty operates within the Financial Services sector, specifically in specialty insurance. Its business model blends traditional insurance underwriting with a membership and lifestyle platform, making it somewhat unique within the broader [financial services landscape](/sector/financial-services).

Is HGTY a growth stock or value stock?

Based on its UQS profile, HGTY leans toward growth — the Growth pillar is rated Good, reflecting expansion in its core markets. The Valuation pillar is also rated Good, meaning it does not carry the premium typically associated with pure growth stocks, giving it a blended character.

Unlock Full HGTY Analysis

Sign in to unlock the detailed analysis behind the UQS Score.

  • View the complete five-pillar UQS Score breakdown
  • Access detailed financial metrics and trend data
  • Compare HGTY against peers on quality and risk
  • See how Valuation and Growth scores are calculated
  • Track score changes over time with Pro alerts
  • Explore curated screeners for specialty insurance stocks
Analyze HGTY in Detail →

Pro Analysis

HGTY — Score History

4045505560Apr 2Apr 12Apr 22May 2May 12May 22May 24v5
Score changes· 23 most recent
DateUQSQualityMoatGrowthRiskValueChange
May 23, 202646.338.447.061.523.361.4+0.2
May 21, 202646.138.047.061.523.360.6-0.7
May 15, 202646.838.947.062.523.362.3-0.1
May 14, 202646.939.047.062.623.362.4-0.1
May 12, 202647.039.347.062.623.363.0-3.5
May 7, 202650.550.947.062.726.563.5+0.1
May 3, 202650.450.947.062.726.562.9+0.1
Apr 26, 202650.350.947.062.726.561.9+0.1
Apr 25, 202650.250.947.062.726.561.6-0.3
Apr 21, 202650.550.947.062.726.563.2+0.1

HGTY — Pillar Breakdown

Quality

38.4/100 (25%)

Hagerty, Inc. has average quality metrics, with room for improvement in margins or capital efficiency.

Return on EquityStrong

Profitability relative to shareholders' equity.

Operating ProfitabilityWeak

Ability to convert revenue into operating profit.

Net ProfitabilityWeak

Bottom-line profit as a share of revenue.

Cash GenerationModerate

Free cash flow relative to market value.

Growth

61.5/100 (20%)

Hagerty, Inc. demonstrates healthy growth trends across revenue and earnings.

Recent Revenue TrendModerate

Revenue trajectory over the last twelve months.

3Y Revenue CAGRModerate

Compound annual revenue growth rate over 3 years.

EPS GrowthStrong

Year-over-year earnings per share growth.

Forward Revenue OutlookWeak

Analyst consensus for future revenue growth.

Forward EPS GrowthStrong

Analyst consensus for future earnings growth.

Risk

23.3/100 (15%)

Hagerty, Inc. presents elevated risk with concerns around leverage or financial stability.

Debt/EquityModerate

Total debt relative to shareholder equity.

Current RatioWeak

Short-term liquidity — ability to pay near-term obligations.

Interest CoverageWeak

Earnings capacity relative to interest payments.

Valuation

61.4/100 (15%)

Hagerty, Inc. trades at a reasonable valuation with decent earnings yield and FCF multiples.

Earnings YieldModerate

Inverse of forward P/E — higher yield means cheaper stock.

Price to Free Cash FlowStrong

How many years of FCF the market cap represents.

PEG RatioStrong

P/E relative to earnings growth — lower is more attractive.

EV/EBITDA vs SectorWeak

Enterprise value multiple relative to sector median.

Moat

47/100 (25%)

Hagerty, Inc. possesses some competitive advantages but faces meaningful competition. The Moat pillar evaluates competitive advantages across five dimensions: Switching Costs, Network Effects, Cost Advantage, Intangible Assets, and Scale & Ecosystem. Sign in to customize moat ratings for HGTY.

Score Composition

Quality
38.4×25%9.6
Growth
61.5×20%12.3
Risk
23.3×15%3.5
Valuation
61.4×15%9.2
Moat
47.0×25%11.8
Total
46.3Below Average

Financial Data

More Stock Analysis

How is the HGTY UQS Score Calculated?

The UQS (Unified Quality Score) for Hagerty, Inc. is calculated using a proprietary 6-pillar framework with 29 financial metrics. Each pillar evaluates a different dimension on a 0–100 scale, then combines into a single weighted score. Scoring thresholds are calibrated per sector. Momentum is an optional Pro toggle — without it, you get the 5-pillar / 25-metric core shown below.

Quality (25%) measures profitability and capital efficiency — ROIC, ROE, margins, GP/Assets, and FCF Yield.

Moat (25%) assesses Hagerty, Inc.'s competitive advantages across switching costs, network effects, cost advantages, intangible assets, and ecosystem scale.

Growth (20%) tracks revenue trajectory and earnings momentum, combining historical results with analyst forward estimates.

Risk (15%) is inversely scored — lower leverage and strong balance sheet health result in higher scores.

Valuation (15%) measures whether Hagerty, Inc. is fairly priced using earnings yield, price-to-FCF, PEG ratio, and EV/EBITDA relative to sector peers.

Six investor-inspired presets are available, each with different pillar weights: Balanced, Buffett, Munger, Lynch, Cathie Wood, and Graham. The public score shown here uses the Balanced preset. Learn more in our FAQ.