ASIC

Financial Services

Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC · Insurance - Property & Casualty · $990M

UQS Score — Balanced Preset
70.0
Good

Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC scores 70.0/100 using the Balanced preset.

UQS vs Financial Services Sector
ASIC
70.0
Sector avg
39.7
Quality
Good
Moat
Weak
Growth
Good
Risk
Strong
Valuation
Attractive

What is Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC?

Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC is a New York-based specialty insurer focused on serving small to medium-sized businesses across the United States. Operating through subsidiaries, it delivers property and casualty insurance and reinsurance solutions to an underserved commercial segment.

Ategrity Specialty generates revenue by underwriting property and casualty insurance and reinsurance products tailored to small and medium-sized business clients. Rather than competing in the crowded personal lines market, the company targets commercial risks that larger carriers often overlook or price inconsistently. Its subsidiary structure allows it to manage underwriting, claims, and risk transfer within a coordinated platform, keeping operations focused on specialty commercial coverage.

Incorporated in 2017 and headquartered in New York, Ategrity Specialty operates as a subsidiary of Zimmer Financial Services Group LLC.

  • Property insurance for small to mid-sized businesses
  • Casualty insurance products for commercial clients
  • Reinsurance solutions through subsidiary operations
  • Specialty coverage for underserved commercial risks

Is ASIC a Good Stock to Buy?

UQS Score rates ASIC as Very Good overall, reflecting a balanced profile with notable strengths across several key dimensions.

The Growth and Risk pillars both register as Strong, suggesting the business is expanding at a meaningful pace while maintaining a risk profile that compares favorably within the financial services sector. Valuation is rated Attractive, meaning the stock does not appear to carry the premium pricing that often accompanies high-growth insurers.

The Moat pillar registers as Weak, indicating that durable competitive advantages — such as brand loyalty or proprietary distribution — are not yet clearly established for this relatively young company.

See the exact pillar breakdown and full financial metrics by signing up for a UQS Pro account. Sign up free →

Past performance does not guarantee future results. UQS Score is based on fundamental data and is not a buy/sell recommendation.

Does ASIC pay dividends?

No — Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC does not currently pay a dividend.

ASIC does not currently pay a dividend. As a recently incorporated specialty insurer still building scale, the company appears to prioritize reinvesting capital into underwriting capacity and operational growth rather than returning cash to shareholders. Investors seeking income from this position should factor that into their broader portfolio planning.

When does ASIC report earnings?

Ategrity Specialty Holdings reports earnings on a quarterly cadence, consistent with standard practice for US-listed equities.

The company's Strong Growth pillar rating suggests its top-line trajectory has been meaningful relative to sector peers. As a small-cap specialty insurer, quarterly results can reflect underwriting cycle dynamics and loss ratio fluctuations that are worth monitoring over time.

For the most recent quarter's results and guidance, visit Ategrity Specialty Holdings' investor relations page directly.

ASIC Price History

-4.3% over 5Y

Monthly close, adjusted for stock splits and dividend reinvestment.

ASIC Long-term Outlook

The combination of a Strong Growth pillar and an Attractive Valuation label positions ASIC as a company where fundamental expansion may not yet be fully reflected in market pricing. The Strong Risk pillar adds further confidence that near-term operational headwinds appear manageable. However, the Weak Moat rating is a reminder that sustaining growth over the long run will depend on whether the company can build more durable competitive positioning in specialty commercial insurance.

Growth drivers

  • Expanding demand for specialty commercial property and casualty coverage among small and mid-sized businesses
  • Potential to deepen market share in underserved commercial insurance segments
  • Reinsurance capabilities that support scalable underwriting capacity

Key risks

  • Limited competitive moat in a fragmented specialty insurance market
  • Exposure to catastrophic loss events that can pressure casualty and property underwriting results
  • Early-stage operational scale that may limit pricing power relative to larger carriers

ASIC vs Peers

ASIC operates in a competitive specialty insurance landscape alongside several other small-cap and niche financial services companies.

MHLAASIC scores higher
Maiden Holdings, Ltd. 6.625 NT 2046

Maiden Holdings operates primarily as a reinsurance-focused entity with a different capital structure, offering fixed-income exposure rather than pure equity upside.

UFCSASIC scores higher
United Fire Group, Inc.

United Fire Group is a more established regional insurer with a longer operating history and a dividend-paying track record that contrasts with ASIC's growth-oriented profile.

UVEASIC scores higher
Universal Insurance Holdings, Inc.

Universal Insurance concentrates heavily on homeowners coverage in catastrophe-prone states, giving it a distinct geographic and product risk profile compared to ASIC's commercial specialty focus.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does Ategrity Specialty Holdings do?

Ategrity Specialty Holdings provides property and casualty insurance and reinsurance products to small and medium-sized businesses in the United States. Operating through subsidiaries and backed by Zimmer Financial Services Group, it focuses on commercial specialty risks that larger, generalist insurers often underserve.

Does ASIC pay dividends?

No, ASIC does not currently pay a dividend. As a growth-oriented specialty insurer incorporated in 2017, the company appears to channel available capital back into underwriting and business development rather than distributing it to shareholders.

When does ASIC report earnings?

Ategrity Specialty Holdings follows a standard quarterly earnings cadence for US-listed companies. For exact reporting dates and the most recent results, check the company's official investor relations page.

Is ASIC a good stock to buy?

UQS Score rates ASIC as Very Good, driven by Strong Growth and Risk pillar ratings alongside an Attractive Valuation label. The Weak Moat pillar is a consideration for investors weighing long-term durability. The full pillar breakdown is available to UQS Pro members.

Is ASIC overvalued?

The UQS Valuation pillar for ASIC is rated Attractive, suggesting the stock is not trading at a significant premium relative to its fundamental profile. This does not guarantee price appreciation, but it indicates valuation is not a primary concern based on the current UQS analysis.

How does ASIC compare to its competitors?

Compared to peers like United Fire Group and Universal Insurance Holdings, ASIC is a younger, more growth-focused specialty insurer without an established dividend. Its Attractive Valuation and Strong Growth ratings differentiate it, though its Weak Moat suggests it has yet to build the same competitive entrenchment as more seasoned carriers.

What is ASIC's market cap bracket?

ASIC is classified as a small-cap company. This means it carries the growth potential often associated with smaller insurers but also the liquidity and volatility considerations that come with operating at a smaller scale within the financial services sector.

Who founded Ategrity Specialty Holdings?

Ategrity Specialty Holdings was incorporated in 2017 and operates as a subsidiary of Zimmer Financial Services Group LLC. Detailed founding history and leadership background are publicly available through the company's official disclosures and investor relations materials.

Is ASIC a long-term quality investment?

From a long-term quality perspective, ASIC's Strong Growth and Risk pillar ratings are encouraging signals. However, the Weak Moat rating suggests the company has not yet demonstrated the durable competitive advantages that typically underpin the strongest long-term compounders in the insurance sector.

What is the main competitive advantage of Ategrity Specialty Holdings?

Ategrity's focus on specialty commercial insurance for small and mid-sized businesses allows it to target a segment that generalist carriers often price inconsistently. However, the UQS Moat pillar currently rates this advantage as Weak, indicating that a clearly defensible market position is still developing.

What sector does ASIC belong to?

ASIC operates in the Financial Services sector, specifically within the property and casualty insurance and reinsurance industry. Its commercial specialty focus places it in a niche that differs from personal lines insurers and diversified financial conglomerates.

Is ASIC a growth stock or value stock?

Based on UQS pillar labels, ASIC exhibits characteristics of both. The Growth pillar is rated Strong, reflecting meaningful business expansion, while the Valuation pillar is rated Attractive — suggesting the stock is not priced at a typical growth premium. This combination may appeal to investors seeking growth at a reasonable price.

Unlock Full ASIC Analysis

Sign in to unlock the detailed analysis behind the UQS Score.

  • View the complete five-pillar UQS Score breakdown
  • Access detailed financial metrics and trend data
  • Compare ASIC against sector peers side by side
  • Track valuation and risk changes over time
  • Get the full analyst-grade quality profile for ASIC
Analyze ASIC in Detail →

Pro Analysis

ASIC — Score History

55606570758085Apr 2Apr 12Apr 22May 2May 12May 22May 24v5
Score changes· 27 most recent
DateUQSQualityMoatGrowthRiskValueChange
May 23, 202669.869.732.074.9100.095.9-0.2
May 21, 202670.070.332.074.9100.096.20.0
May 17, 202670.070.332.074.9100.096.40.0
May 16, 202670.070.332.074.9100.096.70.0
May 14, 202670.070.732.074.9100.096.60.0
May 13, 202670.074.432.074.9100.096.40.0
May 11, 202670.074.432.074.9100.096.3+6.2
May 9, 202663.879.332.033.6100.094.8-0.9
May 5, 202664.770.832.074.963.696.6+0.1
May 4, 202664.670.432.074.963.696.30.0

ASIC — Pillar Breakdown

Quality

69.7/100 (25%)

Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC shows solid profitability with healthy returns on capital and reasonable margins.

Return on EquityStrong

Profitability relative to shareholders' equity.

Operating ProfitabilityModerate

Ability to convert revenue into operating profit.

Net ProfitabilityStrong

Bottom-line profit as a share of revenue.

Cash GenerationModerate

Free cash flow relative to market value.

Growth

74.9/100 (20%)

Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC demonstrates healthy growth trends across revenue and earnings.

Recent Revenue TrendStrong

Revenue trajectory over the last twelve months.

EPS GrowthStrong

Year-over-year earnings per share growth.

Forward Revenue OutlookStrong

Analyst consensus for future revenue growth.

Forward EPS GrowthStrong

Analyst consensus for future earnings growth.

Risk

100.0/100 (15%)

Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC carries minimal financial risk with conservative leverage and strong solvency.

Debt/EquityStrong

Total debt relative to shareholder equity.

Current RatioStrong

Short-term liquidity — ability to pay near-term obligations.

Interest CoverageStrong

Earnings capacity relative to interest payments.

Valuation

97.1/100 (15%)

Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC appears attractively valued relative to its earnings, cash flows, and sector peers.

Earnings YieldStrong

Inverse of forward P/E — higher yield means cheaper stock.

Price to Free Cash FlowStrong

How many years of FCF the market cap represents.

PEG RatioStrong

P/E relative to earnings growth — lower is more attractive.

EV/EBITDA vs SectorStrong

Enterprise value multiple relative to sector median.

Moat

32/100 (25%)

Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC operates in a highly competitive environment with limited sustainable advantages. The Moat pillar evaluates competitive advantages across five dimensions: Switching Costs, Network Effects, Cost Advantage, Intangible Assets, and Scale & Ecosystem. Sign in to customize moat ratings for ASIC.

Score Composition

Quality
69.7×25%17.4
Growth
74.9×20%15.0
Risk
100.0×15%15.0
Valuation
97.1×15%14.6
Moat
32.0×25%8.0
Total
70.0Good

Financial Data

More Stock Analysis

How is the ASIC UQS Score Calculated?

The UQS (Unified Quality Score) for Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC is calculated using a proprietary 6-pillar framework with 29 financial metrics. Each pillar evaluates a different dimension on a 0–100 scale, then combines into a single weighted score. Scoring thresholds are calibrated per sector. Momentum is an optional Pro toggle — without it, you get the 5-pillar / 25-metric core shown below.

Quality (25%) measures profitability and capital efficiency — ROIC, ROE, margins, GP/Assets, and FCF Yield.

Moat (25%) assesses Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC's competitive advantages across switching costs, network effects, cost advantages, intangible assets, and ecosystem scale.

Growth (20%) tracks revenue trajectory and earnings momentum, combining historical results with analyst forward estimates.

Risk (15%) is inversely scored — lower leverage and strong balance sheet health result in higher scores.

Valuation (15%) measures whether Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC is fairly priced using earnings yield, price-to-FCF, PEG ratio, and EV/EBITDA relative to sector peers.

Six investor-inspired presets are available, each with different pillar weights: Balanced, Buffett, Munger, Lynch, Cathie Wood, and Graham. The public score shown here uses the Balanced preset. Learn more in our FAQ.